Weine bewertenRate Wines
Select Item:
Rate Wines
Again and again we read of wine reviews. A wine for example, has 15 out of 20 points. Is that good or not? The question can be answered not. One has to know, which has used marking scheme of the wine tasters, and even then there are still differences between the individual testers.
International is becoming a common thing is to use a 100-point system. This starts at 50 or 60, often only at 70 points and goes up to 100 points for a "perfect" wine. However, while a comparison of scores between 100-point system is not possible with each other. Many publications (especially in Germany) use a very generous 100-point system.
In the wine tasters evaluate our leaders after a rigorous, sophisticated 100-point system. The participants in the Wein-Plus Forum have even agreed on a common 20-point system, now there is also increasingly a 100-point system used.
Overall
| 100 Wein-Plus | Assessment | Description | 20 | 100 |
| 70-74 | Acceptable | With no real errors, but rather bland, neutral and thin in many cases simple. In general, no varietal typicity. Acceptable at prices less than 3 €. | approximately 10 to 11.5 | approximately 76 -79 |
| 75-79 | Properly Good to | Clean varietal character and harmonious wines for every occasion. Absolutely recommended, especially if the prices do not exceed € 5. | approximately 11.5 to 13 | approximately 80-84 |
| 80-84 | Very well | Clean, pure, harmonious wine with a distinct character and style. Each time a drinking pleasure. Under 8 € a favorable purchase. | approximately 13-15 | approximately 85-88 |
| 85-89 | Excellent | Wines of exceptional quality that merit the attention of any discerning wine drinker. Up to 15 € is always an opportunity. | approximately 15 to 16.5 | approximately 89-92 |
| 90-94 | Excellent | First-class wines that are among the best of its kind. Perfect balance, absolute purity and a distinctive character must be given. Less than 20 € always a bargain, but also to about 30 € is not really expensive. | approximately 16.5 to 18 | approximately 93-95 |
| 95-99 | Large | World-class wines, offering an unforgettable sensory experience and are capable of every wine lover to completely captivate you. They are prices of 40 € and above worth it. | approximately 18-20 | approximately 95 -100 |
| 100 | Unique | Weep to think of them, they could do better in some form, beyond my imagination. | 20 | 100 |
Breakdown
Whoever it is preferable to calculate a points result by summation of points in each of the criteria can be used to identify assessment use the following scheme:
Sampling criteria |
| ||||||||||
| Divided into color appearance 0 - 2 points |
| ||||||||||
| and clarity (purity) 0 - 2 points |
| ||||||||||
| Smell (flowers, aroma, bouquet substances) 0 - 4 points |
| ||||||||||
| Flavors (fruit, body, sweetness, acidity, Tannins, clean aromas, structure) 0-7 points |
| ||||||||||
| Overall impression (Overall quality, Typicity, balance / harmony, finesse, finish, state of development / maturity) 0 - 5 points |
| ||||||||||
| Maximum sum |
|
This scheme is based on an evaluation scheme of the journal VINARIA and was added or modified.
Only one request: If you in the future someone asks "How was the wine?" then please do not reply with "15.5 points," but to describe the wine. Points can not taste that is.
An assessment is only possible objective assessment of the quality of a wine. This does not necessarily reflect the level of enjoyment that you have to drink this wine in a particular situation (food, temperature, environment, personal mood, etc.). Take a very young, tannic red wine, for example with very high quality. This is probably getting a very high score for quality; enjoy it but certainly not ready.
Utz Graafmann
| Werbung |
 |